24 Open query

#$&*

course PHY 201

11/20/2011 12:17 AM

024. `query 24

*********************************************

Question: `qWhy was it necessary to let the

string go slack at the top of the circle in

order to get the desired results?

YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Your solution:

confidence rating #$&*:

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

.............................................

Given Solution:

`a** If the string goes slack just at the

instant the weight reaches the 'top' of its

circular path then we are assured that the

centripetal acceleration is equal to the

acceleration of gravity.

If there is tension in the string then the

weight is being pulled downward and therefore

toward the center by a force that exceeds its

weight.

If the string goes slack before the weight

reaches the top of its arc then the path isn't

circular and our results won't apply to an

object moving in a circular arc. **

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

Self-critique (if necessary):

I understand what you are talking about but how

was I supposed to figure this out based on the

question above. I read the text and have

looked at the lab for this section but I could

not find a reference to a washer on a string.

------------------------------------------------

Self-critique Rating:0

*********************************************

Question: `qWhy do you expect that, if the

string is released exactly at the top of the

circle, the initial velocity of the washer will

be horizontal?

YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Your solution:

If the string is released at EXACTLY the top of

the circle it will travel along a tangent of

the point exactly at the top the circle. This

tangent is in the horizontal.

confidence rating #$&*:

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

.............................................

Given Solution:

`a** The direction of an object moving in a

circular arc is perpendicular to a radial line

(i.e., a line from the center to a point on the

circle). When the object is at the 'top' of its

arc it is directly above the center so the

radial line is vertical. Its velocity, being

perpendicular to this vertical, must be

entirely in the horizontal direction. **

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

Self-critique (if necessary):

------------------------------------------------

Self-critique Rating:OK

*********************************************

Question: `qWhat is the centripetal

acceleration of the washer at the instant of

release, assuming that it is released at the

top of its arc and that it goes slack exactly

at this point, and what was the source of this

force?

YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Your solution:

-9.8m/s^2???

confidence rating #$&*:

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

.............................................

Given Solution:

`a** Under these conditions, with the string

slack and not exerting any force on the object,

the centripetal acceleration will be equal to

the acceleration of gravity. **

STUDENT QUESTION: could this answer be

achieved from the equation given

INSTRUCTOR RESPONSE: This conclusion is drawn

simply because the object is traveling in a

circular arc, and at this position the string

is not exerting any force on it. The only force

acting on it at this position is the

gravitational force. Therefore its centripetal

acceleration is equal to the acceleration of

gravity.

Knowing the radius of the circle and v, this

allows us to make a good estimate of the

acceleration of gravity.

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

Self-critique (if necessary):

------------------------------------------------

Self-critique Rating:OK

*********************************************

Question: `qQuery principles of physics and

general college physics 7.02. Delivery truck 18

blocks north, 10 blocks east, 16 blocks south.

What is the final displacement from the origin?

YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Your solution:

If you sketch the path of the truck you have

what amounts to a trapezoid. If you extend the

short side and copy the width you will have

constructed a right triangle whose hypotenuse

depicts the displacement of the truck from its

point of origin.

sqrt(10^2+2^2)=10.2 blocks NE at

tan^-1(2/10)=11.3 degrees

10.2 blocks at 11.3 degrees North of East

confidence rating #$&*:

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

.............................................

Given Solution:

`aThe final position of the truck is 2 blocks

south and 10 blocks east. This is equivalent to

a displacement of +10 blocks in the x direction

and -2 blocks in the y direction.

The distance is therefore sqrt( (10 blocks)^2 +

(-2 blocks)^2 ) = sqrt( 100 blocks^2 + 4

blocks^2)

= sqrt(104 blocks^2)

= sqrt(104) * sqrt(blocks^2)

= 10.2 blocks.

The direction makes and angle of

theta = arcTan(-2 blocks / (10 blocks) ) =

arcTan(-.2) = -12 degrees

with the positive x axis, as measured

counterclockwise from that axis. This puts the

displacement at an angle of 12 degrees in the

clockwise direction from that axis, or 12

degrees south of east.

STUDENT QUESTION:

Why don’t we add 180 to the angle since the y

is negative?

INSTRUCTOR RESPONSE:

We add 180 degrees when the x component is

negative, not when the y component is negative.

You that 168 degrees is in

the second quadrant, where the y component is

positive.

The arctan gives us -12 degrees, which is in

the fourth quadrant (where the y component is

negative and the x component

positive, consistent with the given

information).

We often want an angle between 0 and 360 deg;

when the vector is in the fourth quadrant, so

that the angle is negative, we

can always add 360 degrees to get an equivalent

angle (called a 'coterminal' angle,

'coterminal' meaning 'ending at the same

point'). In this case the angle could be

expressed as -12 degrees or -12 degrees = 360

degrees = 348 degrees. Either angle

specifies a vector at 12 degrees below

horizontal.

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

Self-critique (if necessary):

The truck went 18 blocks North and only 16

blocks South. Why would the angle be -12

degrees??

------------------------------------------------

Self-critique Rating:3

@&

My first statement was that the truck is '2 blocks south'. Clearly that isn't correct, it's 2 blocks north. So your solution is correct.

*@

*********************************************

Question: `qQuery principles of physics and

general college physics 7.18: Diver leaves

cliff traveling in the horizontal direction at

1.8 m/s, hits the water 3.0 sec later. How high

is the cliff and how far from the base does he

land?

YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Your solution:

Distance from the base of the cliff is

1.8m/s*3.0s=5.4m.

vf_vert=v0+(a*'dt),

vf_vert=0m/s+(9.8m/s^2)*3s,

vf_vert=29.4m/s

'ds=((vf+v0)/2)*'dt

'ds_vert=(29.4m/s)/2 * 3.0s

'ds_vert=44m approx

confidence rating #$&*:

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

.............................................

Given Solution:

`aThe diver's initial vertical velocity is

zero, since the initial velocity is horizontal.

Vertical velocity is characterized by the

acceleration of gravity at 9.8 m/s^2 in the

downward direction. We will choose downward as

the positive direction, so the vertical motion

has v0 = 0, constant acceleration 9.8 m/s^2 and

time interval `dt = 3.0 seconds.

The third equation of uniformly accelerated

motion tells us that the vertical displacement

is therefore

vertical motion: `ds = v0 `dt + .5 a `dt^2 = 0

* 3.0 sec + .5 * 9.8 m/s^2 * (3.0 sec)^2 = 0 +

44 m = 44 m.

The cliff is therefore 44 m high.

The horizontal motion is characterized 0 net

force in this direction, resulting in

horizontal acceleration zero. This results in

uniform horizontal velocity so in the

horizontal direction v0 = vf = vAve. Since v0 =

1.8 m/s, vAve = 1.8 m/s and we have

horizontal motion: `ds = vAve * `dt = 1.8 m/s *

3.0 s = 5.4 meters.

STUDENT COMMENT/QUESTION

Why do we not calculate the magnitude for this

problem, I know the number are identical but it

seems that this would tell us how far from the

base the diver traveled?

I understand how to calculate the magnitude

using the pythagorean theorem and the

directions using arc tan, but I am not quite

clear on why and when it is neccessary. ?

INSTRUCTOR RESPONSE

The diver doesn't travel a straight-line path.

His path is part of a parabola. It would be

possible to calculate the distance traveled

along his parabolic arc. However that would

require calculus (beyond the scope of your

course) and while it would be an interesting

exercise, it wouldn't contribute much to

understanding the physics of the situation.

What you did calculate using the Pythagorean

theorem is the magnitude of the displacement

from start to finish, i.e. the straight-line

distance from start to finish.

The diver's displacement is a vector with a

magnitude (which you calculated) and and angle

(which you could easily have calculated using

the arcTangent). However this vector is not in

the direction of any force or acceleration

involved in the problem, and it's not required

to answer any of the questions posed by this

situation. So in this case the displacement

not particularly important for the physics of

the situation.

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

Self-critique (if necessary):

------------------------------------------------

Self-critique Rating:OK

*********************************************

Question: `qGen phy 3.13 A 44 N at 28 deg, B

26.5 N at 56 deg, C 31.0 N at 270 deg. Give

your solution to the problem.

YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Your solution:

All solutions are approximate

A_x=44N(cos28)=38.8N

A_y=44N(sin28)=20.6N

B_x=26.5N(sin56)=14.8N

B_y=26.5N(sin56)=21.9N

C_x=31N(cos270)=0N

C_y=31N(cos270)=-31N

R_x=A_x+B_x+C_x=38.8N+14.8N+0N=53.6N

R_y=A_y+B_y+C_y=20.6N+21.9N-31N=11.5N

A positive R_x and R_y denotes a first quadrant

vector.

R=sqrt(R_x^2+R_y^2)=54.8N

Theta_R=tan^-1(R_y/R_x)=12.1

The resultant vector is 54.8N at 12.1 degrees

above the horizontal.

confidence rating #$&*:

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

.............................................

Given Solution:

`a** The solution given here is for a previous

edition, in which the forces are

Force A of 66 at 28 deg

Force B of B 40 at 56 deg

Force C of 46.8 at 270 deg

These forces are very close to 2/3 as great as

the forces given in the current edition, and

all correct results will therefore be very

close to 2/3 as great as those given here.

Calculations to the nearest whole number:

A has x and y components Ax = 66 cos(28 deg) =

58 and Ay = 66 sin(28 deg) = 31

Bhas x and y components Bx = 40 cos(124 deg) =

-22 and By = 40 sin(124 deg) = 33

C has x and y components Cx = 46.8 cos(270 deg)

= 0 and Cy = 46.8 sin(270 deg) = -47

A - B + C therefore has components

Rx = Ax-Bx+Cx = 58 - (-22) + 0 = 80 and

Ry = Ay - By + Cy = 31-33-47=-49,

which places it is the fourth quadrant and

gives it magnitude

`sqrt(Rx^2 + Ry^2) = `sqrt(80^2 + (-49)^2) = 94

at angle

tan^-1(Ry / Rx) = tan^-1(-49/53) = -32 deg or

360 deg - 32 deg = 328 deg.

Thus A - B + C has magnitude 93 at angle 328

deg.

B-2A has components

Rx = Bx - 2 Ax = -22 - 2 ( 58 ) = -139 and

Ry = By - 2 Ay = 33 - 2(31) = -29,

placing the resultant in the third quadrant and

giving it magnitude

`sqrt( (-139)^2 + (-29)^2 ) = 142 at angle

tan^-1(Ry / Rx) or tan^-1(Ry / Rx) + 180 deg.

Since x < 0 this gives us angle

tan^-1(-29 / -139) + 180 deg = 11 deg + 180 deg

= 191 deg.

Thus B - 2 A has magnitude 142 at angle 191

deg.

Note that the 180 deg is added because the

angle is in the third quadrant and the inverse

tangent gives angles only in the first or

fourth quandrant ( when the x coordinate is

negative we'll be in the second or third

quadrant and must add 180 deg). **

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

Self-critique (if necessary):

------------------------------------------------

Self-critique Rating:OK

*********************************************

Question: `qUniv. 3.58. (This problem has

apparently been eliminated from recent

editions, due to the now policitally incorrect

nature of the device being thrown. The problem

is a very good one and has been edited to

eliminate politically incorrect references).

Good guys in a car at 90 km/hr are following

bad guys driving their car, which at a certain

instant is 15.8 m in front of them and moving

at a constant 110 km/hr; an electronic jamming

device is thrown by the good guys at 45 deg

above horizontal, as they observe it. This

device must land in the bad guy's car. With

what speed must the device be thrown relative

to the good guys, and with what speed relative

to the ground?

YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Your solution:

'ds =(v0*'dt)+(.5*a*'dt^2)

'dsy =(v0y*'dt)+(.5*g*'dt^2)

'dsy=0m

v0y=v0*(sin45)=.71v0

v0x=v0*(cos45)=.71v0

confidence rating #$&*:

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

.............................................

Given Solution:

`a** The device is thrown at velocity v0 at 45

deg, giving it v0y = .71 v0 and v0x = .71 v0.

The device will return to its original vertical

position so we have `dsy = 0.

Using `dsy = v0y `dt + .5 g `dt^2 with `dsy = 0

and assuming the upward direction to be

positive we obtain

v0y `dt + .5 (-g) `dt^2 = 0 so that

`dt = 0 or `dt = - 2 * v0y / (-g) = 2 * 71 v0 /

g.

In time `dt the horizontal displacement

relative to the car will be

`dsx = v0x `dt + ax `dt; since acceleration ax

in the x direction and v0x = .71 v0 is zero we

have

`dsx = .71 v0 * `dt.

We also know that relative to the first car the

second is moving at 20 km / hr = 20,000 m /

(3600 sec) = 5.55 m/s, approx.; since its

initial position is 15.8 m in front of the

first car we have

`dsx = 15.8 m + 5.55 m/s * `dt.

To keep the equations symbolic we use

x0Relative and vRelative for the relative

initial position and velocity of the second car

with respect to the first.

We thus have three equations:

`dt = 2 * .71 v0 / g = 1.42 v0 / g.

`dsx = .71 v0 * `dt

`dsx = x0Relative + v0Relative * `dt.

This gives us three equations in the variables

v0, `dt and `dsx, which we reduce to two by

substituting the expression -2 to obtain:

`dsx = .71 v0 * 1.42 v0 / g = v0^2 / g

`dsx = x0Relative + v0Relative * 1.42 v0 / g.

Setting the right-hand sides equal we have

v0^2 / g = x0Relative + v0Relative * 1.42 v0 /

g, or

v0^2 - v0Relative * 1.42 v0 - g * x0Relative =

0.

We get

v0 = [1.42 v0Relative +-sqrt( (1.42

v0Relative)^2 - 4 * (-g * x0Relative) ) ] / 2 =

[1.42 * v0Relative +-sqrt( (1.42 * v0Relative)

^2 + 4 * g * x0Relative) ] / 2.

Substituting 5.55 m/s for v0Relative and 15.8 m

for x0Relative we get

[1.42 * 5.55 m/s +-sqrt( (1.42 *5.55 m/s)^2 + 4

* 9.8 m/s^2 *15.8 m) ] / 2 =

17 m/s or -9.1 m/s, approx..

We conclude that the initial velocity with

respect to the first case must be 17 m/s.

Checking this we see that the device will have

initial x and y velocities 7.1 * 17 m/s = 12

m/s, approx., and will therefore stay aloft for

2 * 12 m/s / (9.8 m/s^2) = 2.4 sec, approx..

It will therefore travel 2.4 sec * 12 m/s = 28

m, approx. in the horizontal direction relative

to the first car.

During this time the second car will travel

about 5.55 m/s * 2.4 sec = 13 m, approx.,

resulting in relative position 15.8 m + 13 m =

28.8 m with respect to the first. This is

reasonably close to the 28 m obtained from the

motion of the projectile.

Correcting for roundoff errors will result in

precise agreement. **

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

Self-critique (if necessary):

I tried to solve this by reading the solution

but could not. I understood starting with the

third equation of uniform acceleration but I

could not follow the solution after that.

------------------------------------------------

Self-critique Rating:1

@&

This is a University Physics question, a bit more complex than the questions encountered in your course. You don't have the text so you don't have the full statement of the problem. So there's no need to worry about this one.

*@

"

Self-critique (if necessary):

------------------------------------------------

Self-critique rating:

"

Self-critique (if necessary):

------------------------------------------------

Self-critique rating:

#*&!

&#Your work looks good. See my notes. Let me know if you have any questions. &#