Assignment 3

course Phy 202

I understand why you would not want to grant someone in my place in the course an extension. I'm going to do my best to pick up the pace a great deal this week.

???U???????assignment #003

It's not a matter of wanting to. You are obviously a capable student and I hope it's possible to grant the extension. It's more a matter of how far I can stretch the policy, and also what's best for the student. If it doesn't look like there's much hope of success, it's usually not beneficial to the student to prolong the process.

003.

Physics II

07-27-2007

......!!!!!!!!...................................

18:24:18

In your own words explain the meaning of the electric field.

......!!!!!!!!...................................

RESPONSE -->

The electric field is defined as the force on a test charge, which is small enough not to alter the other points of charge that make up the field around a charge.

confidence assessment: 2

.................................................

......!!!!!!!!...................................

18:24:49

STUDENT RESPONSE AND INSTRUCTOR COMMENT: electric field is the concentration of the electrical force

** That's a pretty good way to put it. Very specifically electric field measures the magnitude and direction of the electrical force, per unit of charge, that would be experienced by a charge placed at a given point. **

......!!!!!!!!...................................

RESPONSE -->

self critique assessment: 3

.................................................

......!!!!!!!!...................................

18:28:49

Query Principles of Physics and General Physics problem 16.15 charges 6 microC on diagonal corners, -6 microC on other diagonal corners of 1 m square; force on each.

What is the magnitude and direction of the force on the positive charge at the lower left-hand corner?

......!!!!!!!!...................................

RESPONSE -->

3.24x10^7 C toward the center of the square.

confidence assessment: 1

Try to give not only the answer but the details of the process by which you obtained your answer.

.................................................

......!!!!!!!!...................................

18:48:27

07-27-2007 18:48:27

** The charges which lie 1 meter apart are unlike and therefore exert attractive forces; these forces are each .324 Newtons. This is calculated using Coulomb's Law: F = 9 * 10^9 N m^2/C^2 * ( 6 * 10^-6 C) * ( 6 * 10^-6 C) / ( 1 m)^2 = 324 * 10^-3 N = .324 N.

Charges across a diagonal are like and separated by `sqrt(2) meters = 1.414 meters, approx, and exert repulsive forces of .162 Newtons. This repulsive force is calculated using Coulomb's Law: F = 9 * 10^9 N m^2/C^2 * ( 6 * 10^-6 C) * ( 6* 10^-6 C) / ( 1.414 m)^2 = 162 * 10^-3 N = .162 N.

The charge at the lower left-hand corner therefore experiences a force of .324 Newtons to the right, a force of .324 Newtons straight upward and a force of .162 Newtons at 45 deg down and to the left (at angle 225 deg with respect to the standard positive x axis, which we take as directed toward the right).

This latter force has components Fy = .162 N sin(225 deg) = -.115 N, approx, and Fx = .162 N cos(225 deg) = -.115 N.

The total force in the x direction is therefore -.115 N + .324 N = .21 N, approx; the total force in the y direction is -.115 N + .324 N = .21 N, approx.

Thus the net force has magnitude `sqrt( (.21 N)^2 + (.21 N)^2) = .29 N at an angle of tan^-1( .21 N / .21 N) = tan^-1(1) = 45 deg.

The magnitude and direction of the force on the negative charge at the lower right-hand corner is obtained by a similar analysis, which would show that this charge experiences forces of .324 N to the left, .324 N straight up, and .162 N down and to the right. The net force is found by standard vector methods to be about .29 N up and to the left. **

......!!!!!!!!...................................

NOTES -------> First and foremost I didn't read the question correctly; I thought it was the same as 16.15 so I copied my answer from the page of work I had done. Aside from that, my method for calculating the force was correct.

I am directionally challenged so I'll try this now with guidance of the solution:

F(from bottom right corner) = .324 N in the positive x direction

F(from top left corner) = .324 N in the positive y direction

r(diagonal) = sqrt(1^2 + 1^2) = 1.414 meters

F(diagonal) = 9.0*10^9 Nm^2/C^2 * (6*10^-6 C)(6*10^-6 C)/ (1.414 m)^2 = .162 N (away from the opposite corner--225 degrees)

Component breakdown:

sin(theta) = opp/hypotenuse

Fy = .162 N sin(225) = -.115 N

cos(theta) = adj/hypotenuse

Fx = .162 N cos(225) = -.115 N

Force in the x direction = -.115 N + .324 N = .209 N

Force in the y direction = -.115 N + .324 N = .209 N

net force = sqrt((.209 N)^2+(.209 N)^2)=.300 N

Tan(theta) = opp/adj

theta = arctan(opp/adj)

theta = arctan(.209 N/.209 N)

theta = 45 degrees

I think I get it now.

.......................................................!!!!!!!!...................................

18:59:37

query university physics 21.68 (22.52 10th edition) 5 nC at the origin, -2 nC at (4 cm, 0).

If 6 nC are placed at (4cm, 3cm), what are the components of the resulting force?

......!!!!!!!!...................................

RESPONSE -->

I don't know whether or not I am to answer this one, but I will try anyway.

Fx = 9.0*10^9 N*C^2/m^2* (5.0*10^-9 C * -2.0*10^-9 C)/ (.04 m)^2

Fx = -5.63*10^-5 N (attractive)

Fy = 9.0*10^9 N*C^2/m^2 * (-2.0*10^-9 C* 6.0*10^-9 C)/ (.03 m)^2

Fy = -1.2*10^-4 N (attractive)

confidence assessment: 1

.................................................

......!!!!!!!!...................................

19:04:25

** The 5 nC charge lies at distance sqrt( 4^2 + 3^2) cm from the 6 nC charge, which is 3 cm from the charge at (4 cm ,0).

The force exerted on the 6 nC charge by the two respective forces have magnitudes .00011 N and .00012 N respectively.

The x and y components of the force exerted by the charge at the origin are in the proportions 4/5 and 3/5 to the total charge, giving respective components .000086 N and .000065 N.

The force exerted by the charge at (4 cm, 0) is in the negative y direction.

So the y component of the resultant are .000065 N - .00012 N = -.000055 N and its x component is .000086 N. **

......!!!!!!!!...................................

RESPONSE -->

I got one step right, but I really don't understand that the x and y components of the charge exerted by the charge at the origin are 4/5 and 3/5 of the total charge.

self critique assessment: 2

If you draw a line segment from one point to the other it runs 4 units in the x direction and 3 units in the y direction. If you make a right triangle of the segment, the run and the rise, you find that the hypotenuse is 5. The run is 4/5 and the rise is 3/5 of the hypotenuse.

The force vector being parallel to this segment has its run equal to 4/5 of its magnitude, and rise equal to 3/5 of the magnitude.

.................................................

......!!!!!!!!...................................

19:06:31

Query univ phy 21.76 (10th edition 22.60) quadrupole (q at (0,a), (0, -a), -2q at origin).

For y > a what is the magnitude and direction of the electric field at (0, y)?

......!!!!!!!!...................................

RESPONSE -->

I've decided that only the questions that query my class name are the ones I'm supposed to answer.

confidence assessment: 3

.................................................

......!!!!!!!!...................................

19:06:48

** The magnitude of the field due to the charge at a point is k q / r^2.

For a point at coordinate y on the y axis, for y > a, we have distances r = y-a, y+a and y.

The charges at these distances are respectively q, q and -2q.

So the field is

k*q/(y - a)^2 + k*q/(y + a)^2 - 2k*q/y^2 = 2*k*q*(y^2 + a^2)/((y + a)^2*(y - a)^2) - 2*k*q/y^2

= 2*k*q* [(y^2 + a^2)* y^2 - (y+a)^2 ( y-a)^2) ] / ( y^2 (y + a)^2*(y - a)^2)

= 2*k*q* [y^4 + a^2 y^2 - (y^2 - a^2)^2 ] / ( y^2 (y + a)^2*(y - a)^2)

= 2*k*q* [y^4 + a^2 y^2 - y^4 + 2 y^2 a^2 - a^4 ] / ( y^2 (y + a)^2*(y - a)^2) = 2*k*q* [ 3 a^2 y^2 - a^4 ] / ( y^2 (y + a)^2*(y - a)^2) .

For large y the denominator is close to y^6 and the a^4 in the numerator is insignifant compared to a^2 y^2 sothe expression becomes

6 k q a^2 / y^4,

which is inversely proportional to y^4. **

......!!!!!!!!...................................

RESPONSE -->

OK

self critique assessment: 3

.................................................

......!!!!!!!!...................................

19:06:58

query univ 22.102 annulus in yz plane inner radius R1 outer R2, charge density `sigma.What is a total electric charge on the annulus?

......!!!!!!!!...................................

RESPONSE -->

confidence assessment: 0

.................................................

......!!!!!!!!...................................

19:07:11

** The total charge on the annulus is the product

Q = sigma * A = sigma * (pi R2^2 - pi R1^2).

To find the field at distance x along the x axis, due to the charge in the annulus, we first find the field due to a thin ring of charge:

The charge in a thin ring of radius r and ring thickness `dr is the product

`dQ = 2 pi r `dr * sigma

of ring area and area density.

From any small segment of this ring the electric field at a point of the x axis would be directed at angle arctan( r / x ) with respect to the x axis. By either formal trigonometry or similar triangles we see that the component parallel to the x axis will be in the proportion x / sqrt(x^2 + r^2) to the magnitude of the field from this small segment.

By symmetry only the xcomponent of the field will remain when we sum over the entire ring.

So the field due to the ring will be in the same proportion to the expression k `dQ / (x^2 + r^2).

Thus the field due to this thin ring will be

magnitude of field due to thin ring: k `dQ / (x^2 + r^2) * x / sqrt (x^2 + r^2) = 2 pi k r `dr * x / (x^2 + r^2)^(3/2).

Summing over all such thin rings, which run from r = R1 to r = R2, we obtain the integral

magnitude of field = integral ( 2 pi k r x /(x^2 + r^2)^(3/2) with respect to r, from R1 to R2).

Evaluating the integral we find that

magnitude of field = 2* pi k *x* | 1 /sqrt(x^2 + r1^2) - 1 / sqrt(x^2 + r2^2) |

The direction of the field is along the x axis.

If the point is close to the origin then x is close to 0 and x / sqrt(x^2 + r^2) is approximately equal to x / r, for any r much larger than x. This is because the derivative of x / sqrt(x^2 + r^2) with respect to x is r^2 / (x^2+r^2)^(3/2), which for x = 0 is just 1/r, having no x dependence. So at small displacement `dx from the origin the field strength will just be some constant multiple of `dx. **

......!!!!!!!!...................................

RESPONSE -->

self critique assessment: 0

.................................................

"

&#

Your work looks good. See my notes. Let me know if you have any questions. &#