Assignment 5 Query

#$&*

course Mth 164

2/21 12

If your solution to stated problem does not match the given solution, you should self-critique per instructions at

http://vhcc2.vhcc.edu/dsmith/geninfo/labrynth_created_fall_05/levl1_22/levl2_81/file3_259.htm

.

Your solution, attempt at solution. If you are unable to attempt a solution, give a phrase-by-phrase interpretation of the problem along with a statement of what you do or do not understand about it. This response should be given, based on the work you did in completing the assignment, before you look at the given solution.

......!!!!!!!!...................................

Precalculus II

Asst # 5

09-23-2001

......!!!!!!!!...................................

08:05:46

......!!!!!!!!...................................

**** Query problem 6.2.8 exact value of tan(195 deg)

......!!!!!!!!...................................

08:46:26

YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Your solution:

tan(195 deg) = tan (390 deg) /2 = tan(30 deg)/2

The point that corresponds to this angle is sqrt(3)/2 , ½).

Using the half-angle Formula for tan alpha/2 we have:

tan(195 deg) = 1 - (sqrt3)/2 / (1/2)

= (2 - sqrt(3))/2 / (1/2)

= (2 - sqrt(3)) / 1

= 2 - sqrt3

confidence rating #$&*: 3

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

.............................................

Given Solution:

** tan(alpha+beta)= [tan(alpha)+tan(beta)]/[1-tan(alpha)tan(beta].

So tan(195 deg) = tan(150 deg + 45 deg) =

[ tan(150 deg) + tan(45 deg) ] / [ 1 - tan(150 deg) * tan(45 deg) ] =

[ -sqrt(3) / 3 + 1 ] / [ 1 - (-sqrt(3)) * 1 ] =

[1 - sqrt(3)/3] / (1 + sqrt(3)/3 )=

(1 - sqrt(3)/3)(1 - sqrt(3)/3) / [ (1+sqrt(3)/3)(1-sqrt(3)/3) ] =

(1 - 2 sqrt(3)/3 + 1/3) / (1 - 1/3) =

(4/3 - 2 sqrt(3)/3) / (2/3) =

2 - sqrt(3). **

STUDENT SOLUTION:

we know that the sum and difference formula will allow us to say that

tan(alpha+beta)=tan(alpha)+tan(beta)/1-tan(alpha)tan(beta).

so for this

problem we can say

tan(180+15)=tan(180)+tan(15)/1-tan(180)tan(15).

but since we do not know the exact value of tan 15 deg we have use the sum and

difference formula to find it. we can say that tan(alpha-beta)= tan(alpha)-

tan(beta)/1+tan(alpha)tan(beta). i chose to use alpha=60 and beta=45 there

is another way this can be done. but i said

tan(60-45)=tan60-tan45/1+tan60tan45

and we know that the tan60=sq.rt.3 from

the chart in chapter 5. we also know that tan 45=1 . so we can say

(sq.rt.3-1)/1+(sq.rt.3)(1).

we can multiply through by the conjugate to get the radical out of the denominator and we have (2sq.rt.3-4)/(-2) .

we could go ahead and say that this is the answer given the fact that tan 180=0 and

we know that 0+tan 15 divided by 1+0 is going to give the same answer but it

will be more profitable to go through all of the steps. so we can say

tan(alpha+beta)=tan(alpha)+tan(beta)/1-tan(alpha)tan(beta). alpha=180 and

beta=15 so we can say that tan(180+15)= 0+(2sq.rt.3-4)/(-2)/

1-(0)(2sq.rt.3-4)/(-2)= ((2sq.rt.3)-4)/(-2)

.........................................

08:46:27

......!!!!!!!!...................................

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

Self-critique (if necessary):

OK

------------------------------------------------

Self-critique Rating: OK

**** what is the exact value of tan(195 deg)?

......!!!!!!!!...................................

YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Your solution:

The exact value of tan(195 deg) is 2- (sqrt3). It is equal to tan (390 deg/2) and tan (30 deg/2).

confidence rating #$&*: 3

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

.............................................

Given Solution:

**** to get this result you used the exact values of two angles to get

tan(15 deg). Which two angles were these, what were the exact values, and

what formula did you use to get your result?

to find the value of tan(15 deg) as i stated in the first problem i used the

two angles 60 deg and 45 deg. i used the sum and difference formula for

tan(alpha-beta) and i let alpha=60 and beta=45. the exact value of tan

60=(sq.rt.3) or approximately 1.73. the value of tan 45=1.

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

Self-critique (if necessary):

OK

------------------------------------------------

Self-critique Rating: OK

**** For which angles between 0 and 90 degrees do you know the exact

value of the trigonometric functions? How many ways are there to combine

angles you have listed to obtain 15 degrees?

......!!!!!!!!...................................

08:55:24

YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Your solution:

Without doing any figuring, we know the exact value of the trigonometric functions for 30 deg, 45 deg and 60 deg between 0 and 90 deg.

There is 2 ways to combine angles listed to obtain 15 degrees and shown as follows:

60 deg - 45 deg = 15 deg

45 deg - 30 deg = 15 deg

confidence rating #$&*: 3

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

.............................................

Given Solution:

for all six trigonometric functions we know the exact values of 5 angles

including 90 deg. we know the exact value for 0 deg. and 30 deg,45 deg, 60

deg,90 deg. there are two ways to obtain an angle of 15 deg. the first way

is the one i used in solving the previous problem which is 60deg-45deg and

the other is 45deg-30deg.

.........................................

08:55:25

......!!!!!!!!...................................

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

Self-critique (if necessary):

OK

------------------------------------------------

Self-critique Rating: OK

**** Query problem 6.2.20 cos(5 `pi / 12) cos(7`pi/12) -

sin(5`pi/12)sin(7`pi/12)

......!!!!!!!!...................................

09:16:29

YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Your solution:

Using the sum formula for the cos function we have:

cos(5pi / 12) cos(7pi / 12) - sin(5pi / 12) sin(7pi / 12) = cos(5pi / 12 + 7pi / 12)

= cos(12pi /12) = cos(pi) = -1

confidence rating #$&*: 3

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

.............................................

Given Solution:

STUDENT SOLUTION: to begin solving this equation it is obvious that we need to simplify.

because each part to this equation can be simplified using the sum and

difference formulas. first we take cos(5pi/12) this can be written as

cos(75deg) we then know that

cos(alpha+beta)=cos(alpha)cos(beta)-sin(alpha)sin(beta).

so we can say

cos(45+30)=cos45cos30-sin45sin30.

(sq.rt.2)/2(sq.rt.3)/2- (sq.rt.2)/2(1/2)

which gives us

(sq.rt.6-sq.rt.2)/4.

we can then simplify the second term in the equation. cos7pi/12. which can

be written as cos(105deg). we can then say

cos(60+45)=cos60cos45-sin60sin45.

which is

(1/2)(sq.rt.2/2)-(sq.rt.3/2)(sq.rt.2/2)=(sq.rt.2-sq.rt.6)/4.

we can now solve for the third term in the equation which is sin(5pi/12) which can

be written as sin75deg. we can then say that

sin(45+30)=sin45cos30+cos45sin30. which is equal to

(sq.rt.2/2)(sq.rt.3/2)+(sq.rt.2/2)(1/2)=(sq.rt.6+sq.rt.2)/4.

we can now solve the fourth term in the equation which is sin7pi/12. which can be

written as sin 105 deg. we can then say

sin(60+45)=sin60cos45+cos60sin45=(sq.rt.3/2)(sq.rt.2/2)+(1/2)(sq.rt.2/2)

=(sq.rt.6+sq.rt.2/4).

we can now solve the equation. (sq.rt.6-sq.rt.2)/4 (sq.rt.2-sq.rt.6)/4

-(sq.rt.6+sq.rt.2)/4(sq.rt.6+sq.rt.2)/4=

(2sq.rt.12)-8/16- (2sq.rt.12)+8/16= 0 .

** great until the last step, which should read

(2sq.rt.12)-8/16- [(2sq.rt.12)+8/16]= -1. **

.........................................

09:16:29

......!!!!!!!!...................................

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

Self-critique (if necessary):

I guess that is the long way to get there.

------------------------------------------------

Self-critique Rating: 3

**** Which sum or difference formula does this expression fit?

......!!!!!!!!...................................

09:22:06

YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Your solution:

The expression fits the right hand side of the sum formula for the cos function.

confidence rating #$&*: 3

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

.............................................

Given Solution:

STUDENT SOLUTION if we look at the entire expression before it has been simplified at all, we

see that it says cos(cos)-sin(sin) which fits the form of the formula for

cos(alpha+beta)=cos(alpha)cos(beta)-sin(alpha)sin(beta).

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

Self-critique (if necessary):

OK

------------------------------------------------

Self-critique Rating: OK

**** If this expression is the right-hand side of a sum or difference

formula, what then is the left-hand side and what is its exact value?

......!!!!!!!!...................................

09:22:54

YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Your solution:

The left hand side of the sum formula for the cos function is cos(alpha + beta). This represents the cos of the sum of two angles.

confidence rating #$&*: 3

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

.............................................

Given Solution:

STUDENT SOLUTION if this expression is the right hand side of the formula then the left hand

side of the formula has to be cos(alpha-beta) and it has to be equal to

zero. because in the sum and distance formulas the two equations must equal

each other.

.........................................

09:22:55

......!!!!!!!!...................................

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

Self-critique (if necessary):

OK

------------------------------------------------

Self-critique Rating: OK

**** Query problem 6.2.38 tan(2 `pi - `theta) = - tan(`theta)

......!!!!!!!!...................................

09:25:15

YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Your solution:

Using the difference formula for the tan function we have:

(tan (2pi) - tan theta) / (1 + tan(2pi) * tan theta)

= (0/1 - tan theta) / (1 + 0/1 * tan theta)

= -tan theta / 1

= -tan theta

confidence rating #$&*: 3

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

.............................................

Given Solution:

to prove this identity we can say that tan(2pi-theta)=-tan theta. to figure

out this problem we use the sum and difference formula for

tan(alpha-beta)=tan 2pi-tan theta/1+tan2pi tan theta

we know that the value of tan of 2pi =0 so we can say

0-tan theta/1+(0)(tan theta=(- tan theta)/1

which is -tan theta so the identity is true.

** Good solution. An alternative would be to use the periodicity and even/odd properties of sine and cosine:

sin(-`theta) = - sin(`theta)

cos(-`theta) = - cos(`theta)

so

tan (-`theta) = - tan(`theta)

all functions have the same values at 2 `pi + `theta as at `theta, so the result follows. **

.........................................

09:25:16

......!!!!!!!!...................................

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

Self-critique (if necessary):

Yes, I see what you mean.

------------------------------------------------

Self-critique Rating: 3

**** how do you establish the given identity?

......!!!!!!!!...................................

09:25:38

YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Your solution:

We establish the identity by using the sum formula for the tan function or by using use the periodicity and even/odd properties of sine and cosine.

confidence rating #$&*: 3

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

.............................................

Given Solution:

STUDENT SOLUTION we establish the identity by using the sum and difference formula for

tan(alpha-beta) where alpha is equal to 2pi and beta is theta. we then say

that (0-tan theta)/1+(0)(tan theta is equal to -tan theta.

.........................................

09:25:39

......!!!!!!!!...................................

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

Self-critique (if necessary):

OK

------------------------------------------------

Self-critique Rating: OK

**** Query problem 6.3.8 find exact values of sin & cos of 2`theta,

and of `theta/2 if csc(`theta) = -`sqrt(5)

......!!!!!!!!...................................

09:27:35

YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Your solution:

csc -sqrt(5) = -1 /sin sqrt(5) therefore sin(theta) = -sqrt(5) / 5

First we need to find cos theta.

Using Pythagorean Theorem we have:

x^2 + (-sqrt(5))^2 = 5^2

x^2 + 5 = 25

x^2 = sqrt(20)

x = 2sqrt(5)

Therefore:

cos theta = 2sqrt(5)/5

Using the double angle formulas we have:

sin(2theta) = 2 * -sqrt(5)/5 * 2sqrt(5)/5 = -20/25 = -4/5

cos(2theta) = 2 * (2sqrt(5)/5)^2 - 1 = 2 * 20/25 - 25/25 = 40/25 - 25/25 = 15/25 = 3/5

Using the half angle formulas we have:

sin (theta/2) = -sqrt[1 - 2sqrt(5)/5 * 1/2] = -sqrt[(5 - 2sqrt(5))/5 * ½]

= -sqrt[(5 - 2sqrt(5))/10]

cos (theta/2) = sqrt[1 + 2sqrt(5)/5 * 1/2] = sqrt[(5 + 2sqrt(5))/5 * ½]

= sqrt[(5 + 2sqrt(5))/10]

confidence rating #$&*: 3

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

.............................................

Given Solution:

csc ' theta = 1/sin 'theta = - sqrt(5) = 1/(-sqrt(5)) = -sqrt(5)/5 = sin 'theta = y/r so y = -sqrt(5) and r = 5.

(-sqrt(5))^2 + x^2 = 5^2 => 5+x^2=25 => c = 2sqrt(5)

cos 'theta = x/r = 2sqrt(5)/5.

sin 2'theta = 2(-sqrt(5)/5)(2sqrt(5)/5) = -20/25 = - 4/5

cos 2'theta = (2sqrt(5)/5)^2 - (-sqrt(5)/5)^2 = 20/25 - 5/25 = 15/25 = 3/5.

sin 'theta/2 = -sqrt[(1-2sqrt(5)/5)/2] = - sqrt[1/2 - sqrt(5)/5]

cos 'theta/2 =sqrt[(1+2sqrt(5)/5)/2] = sqrt[1/2 + sqrt(5)/5]

STUDENT SOLUTIONS

I used the following formulas:

sin(2'theta) = 2 sin'theta * cos'theta

cos(2'theta) = cos^2'theta - sin^2'theta

sin (theta/2) = + - sqrt[(1-cos'theta)/2]

and cos ('theta/2) = + - sqrt[(1+cos'theta)/2]

we know that the csc theta is 1/sin theta or r/b so we can say that

*******

ADDITIONAL STUDENT SOLUTIONS INTERSPERSED WITH INSTRUCTOR COMMENTARY

sin theta=(-sq.rt.5/5)

and if the sin is (-sq.rt.5/5) we can find the cosine by saying that

(-sq.rt.5+x)^2=5^2 so 5+x=25

** Watch the algebra. (a+b)^2 = a^2 + 2 ab + b^2, so

(-sq.rt.5+x)^2 = 5 - 2 x `sqrt(5) + x^2. **

** However you should use sin^2(`theta) + cos^2(`theta) = 1 so

cos^2(`theta) = 1 - sin^2(`theta) and

cos(`theta) = `sqrt[ 1 - sin^2(`theta) ] = `sqrt(1 - (`sqrt(5) / 5)^2 ) = `sqrt(1 - 1/5)^2 = `sqrt(4/5) = 2 `sqrt(5) / 5. **

and the cosine is (sq.rt.20/5) which is 2(sq.rt.5)/5.

so

sin 2 theta=2(-sq.rt.5)(2(sq.rt.5)=2(-2sq.rt25)=-20

next we need to find cos2theta. so we say cos^2 theta-sin^2 theta. so we

have

(2sq.rt.5)^2-(-sq.rt.5)^2=10-5=5

** right strategy but wrong information from previous steps. What should have tipped you off here is that you got 5. The cosine and sine functions can't have absoluted values greater than 1. **

the third part of the problem asks us to solve for sin(theta/2). so we can

use the formula for half angles. which is

sin(alpha/2)=+or- (sq.rt. 1-cos alpha/2).

so we can say

sin(alpha/2)=+or-(sq.rt. 1-2(sq.rt.5)/2) which equals approximately 1.74.

**this strategy won’t work; the correct result can't be > 1 **

the fourth part of the equation asks us to find the value of cos (theta/2).

we can also use the half angle formula to find the value of this expression.

we can say

cos(alpha/2)=+or -(sq.rt. 1+cos alpha/2) which is equal to cos

(alpha/2)=+or- (sq.rt.1+2sq.rt.5)/2= approximately 1.65

** same comment as previous **

.........................................

09:27:35

......!!!!!!!!...................................

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

Self-critique (if necessary):

OK

------------------------------------------------

Self-critique Rating: OK

**** query problems 6.3.42 tan(`theta/2) = csc(`theta) - cot(`theta)

......!!!!!!!!...................................

09:29:37

YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Your solution:

tan(theta/2) = [1 - cos(theta)] / sin(theta) = 1/sin(theta) - cos(theta) / sin(theta)

= csc(theta) - cot(theta)

confidence rating #$&*: 3

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

.............................................

Given Solution:

** The formula in the text is

tan(alpha/2)= (1-cos (alpha)) / sin (alpha) which is the same as

1 / sin(alpha) - cos(alpha) / sin(alpha) =

csc(alpha) - cot(alpha). **

now we know that the

csc theta=1/sin theta

and we also know that

cot theta=cos theta/sin theta.

so we can say

tan(theta/2)=1/sin theta-cos theta/sin theta=1-cos theta/sin theta=sin theta/1+cos theta.

therefore the identiity is true.

.........................................

09:29:37

......!!!!!!!!...................................

________________________________________

Questions about some odd-numbered problems:

Section 2

63. cos(csc^-1(u) Theta = csc^-1 u so that csc theta = u

csc^-1(u) is the base angle of a right triangle whose hypotenuse is u (corresponding to a circle of radius u about the origin) and whose opposite side (the 'y' leg) is 1 (thus csc(theta) = r / y = u / 1 =u).

The adjacent side of this triangle (the 'x' leg) is thus sqrt(u^2 - 1), by the Pythagorean Theorem.

The cosine of the angle is adjacent side / hypotenuse = sqr(1 - u^2) / 1 = sqrt(1 - u^2) (this corresponds to x / r in the circular model).

A similar scheme is used for a variety of problems involving a trig function of an inverse trig function.

69. g^-1(f(7pi/4)) cos^-1(sin(7pi/4)) 0 is less than or equal to x is less than or equal to pi cos^-1(sin7pi/4) = x = 2.356

By the unit circle picture for the multiples of pi / 4, we have sin(7 pi / 4) = -sqrt(2) / 2.

cos^-1(sqrt(2) / 2) is the angle between 0 and pi whose cosine in -sqrt(2) / 2.

The unit circle picture tells us that this angle is 3 pi / 4. That is, cos(3 pi / 4) = -sqrt(2) / 2.

Section 5

41. Show that sin^4(theta) = 3/8 - 1/2cos(2theta) +1/8cos(4theta)

sin^2(theta) = 1 - cos^2(theta), so

sin^4(theta) = (1 - cos^2(theta) ) ^ 2 = 1 - 2 cos^2(theta) + cos^4(theta).

cos(2theta) = cos^2(theta) - sin^2(theta)

4 theta = 2 ( 2 theta) so

cos(4 theta) = cos^2(2 theta) - sin^2(2 theta)

= (cos(2 theta))^2 - sin(2 theta)^2

= ( cos^2(theta) - sin^2(theta))^2 - (2 sin(theta) cos(theta))^2

= cos^4(theta) - 2 cos^2(theta) sin^2(theta) + sin^4(theta) - 4 sin^2(theta) cos^2(theta)

= cos^4(theta) - 2 cos^2(theta) ( 1 - cos^2(theta)) + (1 - cos^2(theta))^2 - 4 ( 1 - cos^2(theta)) cos^2(theta)

Thus you can write sin^4(theta) in terms of powers of cos(theta). You can do the same with cos(2 theta) and cos(4 theta).

This allows you to write the identity

sin^4(theta) = 3/8 - 1/2cos(2theta) +1/8cos(4theta)

in terms of cos(theta). Having done so you can fairly easily verify that the equation holds.

45. Find an expression for sin(5theta) as a 5th-degree polynomial in the variable sin(theta)

Sin(5theta) = sin^2(theta)+sin^2(theta) +sin(theta) ?

sin(5 theta) = sin(4 theta + theta), which is simplified using the formula for sin(a+b).

sin(4 theta) and cos(4 theta) are simplified as the sine and cosine of (2 * 2 theta), using double-angle formulas.

then sin(2 theta) and cos(2 theta) are simplified using the same formula.

any term involving cos^2 can be written as 1 - sin^2

you end up with a 5th-degree polynomial

Establish the identity:

51. sec(2theta) = sec^2(theta)/2-sec^2(theta) = 1/cos^2(theta) *(1/1+cos(2theta)/2) =

sec(2 theta) = 1 / cos(2 theta) = 1 / (cos^2(theta) - sin^2(theta) )

sec^2(theta) / 2 = 1 / (2 cos^2(theta) )

sec^2(theta) = 1 / cos^2(theta)

It would be easy enough to write out the two sides, multiply by a common denominator, etc.

However I don't think you have the signs of grouping right in your first expression. As you're written it the right-hand side would just simplify to -sec^2(theta) / 2.

Can you resubmit this question and clarify the signs of grouping?

For example, could you mean one of the following?

sec^2(theta/2)-sec^2(theta)

sec^2(theta)/(2-sec^2(theta))

63. sin(3theta)/sin(theta)-cos(3theta)/cos(theta) = 2

sin(3 theta) = sin(2 theta + theta) =

sin(2 theta) cos(theta) + cos(2 theta) sin(theta) =

2 sin(theta) cos(theta) * cos(theta) + (cos^2(theta) - sin^2(theta) ) sin(theta) so the first term (dividing this by sin(theta) ) is 2 cos^2 (theta) + cos^2(theta) - sin^2(theta) = 3 cos^2(theta) - sin^2(theta).

cos(3 theta) = cos(2 theta + theta) =

cos(2 theta) cos(theta) - sin(2 theta) sin(theta) =

(cos^2(theta) - sin^2(theta) ) cos(theta) - 2 sin(theta) cos(theta) sin(theta) . Dividing by cos(theta) and simplifying we find that the second term is

- (cos^2(theta) - 3 sin^2(theta) ) .

Combining the two terms we get

2 cos^2(theta) + 2 sin^2(theta) = 2 ( cos^2(theta) + sin^2(theta) ) = 2 * 1 = 2.

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&

Self-critique (if necessary):

OK

------------------------------------------------